One of the best ways to build a thriving microbakery isn’t by constantly chasing new customers—it’s by nurturing the ones you already have. Repeat customers are the foundation of a sustainable business. They trust you, love your products, and—when treated well—become your best marketing tool by telling their friends about you. In this post, we’ll dive into simple, actionable ways to create a great first experience, encourage repeat orders, and build customer loyalty that lasts.
If you’ve ever felt like you’re spending too much time trying to bring in new customers instead of keeping the ones you have, this is for you. Let’s talk about how to create a bakery that customers keep coming back to—again and again.
What Makes Customers Come Back?
Before we talk about strategies, let’s start with why customers reorder in the first place. When you think about your favorite businesses, what keeps you going back? The same principles apply to your bakery.
1. A Great First Experience
A smooth ordering process makes a strong first impression. Reduce friction with a simple pre-order system like Simply Bread or Hot Plate to eliminate confusion and unnecessary back-and-forth messages.
Clear communication is key. Customers should know exactly when and where to pick up their order and what to do if they need to reschedule.
A warm welcome goes a long way. A handwritten “thank you” on the bag or a follow-up message can make customers feel valued and more likely to return.
2. Feeling Connected to Your Brand
People don’t just buy bread—they buy into the story and experience of knowing who made it. That’s the magic of a microbakery.
Show up in Instagram stories or Facebook posts to share behind-the-scenes moments. Let customers feel connected to you.
If possible, greet customers by name when they pick up their orders or interact with them at markets. It builds trust and familiarity.
3. Easy Ordering & Communication
If your ordering process is clunky or confusing, even your most loyal customers might stop ordering.
Make it simple and seamless to place orders, get updates, and ask questions.
Set up an email or text list so customers don’t forget about you.
How to Encourage Repeat Orders
Now that we know why customers come back, let’s talk about how to make it happen.
1. Focus on Excellent Customer Service
Respond to messages quickly and warmly.
Personalize your interactions—use customer names in texts and order confirmations.
Thank customers for their orders, and let them know they are appreciated.
2. Stay in Touch (Without Being Pushy)
Send weekly or biweekly texts or emails when orders open. Many customers forget to place an order simply because life gets busy!
Share sneak peeks of upcoming flavors or limited-edition items to build excitement.
If a regular customer hasn’t ordered in a while, send a friendly check-in: Example
Message: “Hey Sarah! I noticed it’s been a while since you placed an order. No worries if you’re taking a break, but just wanted to let you know our cinnamon rolls are back this weekend if you’re interested!”
Rewarding Repeat Customers
A little VIP treatment goes a long way. Small gestures can make customers feel valued and keep them coming back.
Ideas for Rewarding Loyalty:
Early access to pre-orders for limited-edition items.
A simple punch card (Buy 9 loaves, get the 10th free).
Surprise discounts or freebies (A free cookie or scone added to their order).
With the Simply Bread app, you can now send discount codes to repeat customers—a simple way to show appreciation without overcomplicating your process.
Tracking & Encouraging Your Best Customers
How do you keep track of who your best customers are?
Look at your last 10 orders or bake days—how many were from repeat buyers?
If most of your customers are brand new each week, it’s a sign you need to focus more on retention.
Create a simple Google Sheet to track top customers so you can thank them and offer small perks.
Final Thoughts: Keep It Simple & Intentional
Growing a microbakery isn’t just about getting more customers—it’s about keeping the ones you already have happy, engaged, and excited to order again.
Here’s my challenge for you: Pick one thing from this post and implement it this week. Maybe it’s sending a quick thank-you text, setting up a simple loyalty perk, or making sure your ordering process is as easy as possible. Small efforts add up in big ways.
📌 RESOURCES & LINKS
🌟 Download the FREE Guide and Checklist, Your First Steps to a Successful In-Home Bakery to begin building YOUR thriving microbakery! → Download Here
What’s one thing you’re doing to keep customers coming back? Let me know in the comments or tag me @carolinebower_sourdough on Instagram!
Happy baking!
Try Sunrise Flour Mill Organic Heritage Flour: 20% off Sunrise Flour Mill https://thebreadwinner.captivate.fm/sunrise20
